One reason for this is the sheer diversity of the entities that make
up this complex sector. Many people question whether it is possible to consider small
neighborhood associations and well-financed business associations, tiny soup kitchens
and massive hospital complexes, elite universities and small day-care centers as parts
of a single coherent "sector."
An accurate view of the nonprofit sector has also been clouded by the
myth that government and nonprofit organizations are in constant and fundamental
conflict. In fact, one of the central realities of the nonprofit sector today is its
mutually beneficial involvement with government.
To understand the American nonprofit sector and its role in promoting
civil society, it is necessary to sweep away some of this mythology and look carefully
at the actual operations of this set of institutions.
That nonprofit organizations play such an important role in American
life is due in part to historical accident. American society came into existence before
government appeared on the scene. Frontier settlers therefore had to find ways to
provide needed public services for themselves, without the aid of a pre-existing
governmental apparatus. They did so by joining voluntarily with their neighbors to
create schools, raise barns and build public facilities, as well as many other things.
When Alexis de Tocqueville visited America in the early 19th century,
he was struck by the proliferation of such voluntary groups. "Wherever at the head of
some major undertaking you are sure to find the state in France or a person of wealth in
England," he observed, "you will find an association in America." The deep-seated
hostility to centralized authority that many immigrants brought with them from their
homelands made a virtue out of this necessity, reinforcing the prevailing voluntary
spirit and creating a presumption in favor of "do-it-yourself" approaches to solving
public problems.
Although historical circumstances have changed considerably in the
intervening 150 years, nonprofit organizations continue to play an important role in
American life. More specifically, these organizations perform four crucial roles:
- The Service Role. Reluctant
as they are to call government in to cope with a public problem until private solutions
have been tried first, Americans tend to let nonprofit organizations lead the way in
responding to critical public needs.
- The Value Guardian Role. The
nonprofit sector functions as a "value guardian" in American society, and exemplar and
crucial embodiment of a fundamental national value emphasizing individual initiative for
the public good just as private economic enterprises serve as vehicles for promoting
individual initiative for the private good. In the process, nonprofits foster pluralism,
diversity and freedom.
- The Advocacy/Social Safety-Valve
Role. Nonprofit organizations also play a vital role in mobilizing broader
public attention to societal problems and needs. Indeed, they are the principal vehicle
through which communities can give voice to their concerns.
- The Community Building
Role. Finally, nonprofit organizations play a vital role in creating and
sustaining what scholars have come to refer to as "social capital," i.e., those bonds of
trust and reciprocity that seem to be pivotal for a democratic society and a market
economy to function effectively, but that the American ethic of individualism would
otherwise make it difficult to sustain.